April 2012 Design Tip

When NOT to Draft

Plastic part design can be a complex process under any circumstances, and when you are designing entirely new types of product the challenges can be greater still. In design you rarely know what little trick or idea is going to make the difficult easy or the seemingly impossible possible; that's why we offer new design tips every month. That said, every once in a while we run across one that seems so important that it's worth revisiting. Here is a "Design Tip Classic" from January 2010.

We've talked so often about the need for draft in injection moulded parts that you may be shocked to hear that there are features that not only don't need to be drafted, but that work better if they aren't drafted. It's true, and the reason we haven't mentioned it before is this is a new capability added to our injection moulding process.

The features in question are typically screw holes used to connect plastic parts-front and back halves of a plastic shell, for example-with thread-forming screws. The holes are formed by posts in the mould called "cores" (see Figure 1).

Figure 1: Example of a core used to form a hole in a moulded part.

Figure 1: Example of a core used to form a hole in a moulded part.

Previously, we created cores in the mould by directly milling them from the aluminium mould body. Tall thin cores could "stick" to the plastic part and break off when the parts were ejected. To strengthen these cores and reduce ejection stresses we required them to be drafted as tall narrow cones. The resulting tapered screw holes could be problematic. Unless the screw was also tapered (like a wood screw), it would become tighter as it was screwed into the tapered hole. If it got too tight, it would crack the part. If it was too loose it could "strip" and fail to hold.

Long, straight screws, tapered pilot holes, and knit lines were a bad combination. If the hole and corresponding screw length were short, the part could be safely produced, but designs with deeper holes unfortunately went back to designers as no-quoted parts.

That's all in the past. Now, Protomold can produce high-aspect-ratio small diameter holes using steel core pins in the mould. Say, for example, you are designing a part with a 3/4" deep, 1/8" diameter hole (see Figure 2). You simply include that feature in your 3D CAD model; our proprietary software will go to work and design the mould with a cylindrical steel core pin for forming the hole (see Figure 3).

Figure 2: Sample part with ¾&rdquot; deep holes.

Figure 2: Sample part with ¾" deep holes.

Figure 3: Mould with cylindrical steel core pins for part.

Figure 3: Mould with cylindrical steel core pins for part.

This innovation changes two things for you. First, we can now mould parts with deeper, narrower holes. Second-and here's the shocker-you don't have to draft those features. The reasons are simple. A steel pin is strong enough to handle the stress of ejection and its surface is smooth enough to release cleanly from the part without draft. And, while there shouldn't be any cosmetic effect on the resulting part, if there is, it will be inside the hole where it won't be seen.

The size of the hole in your part will be determined by the size of the thread-forming screw you'll use for assembly. The hole itself will be slightly larger than the minor diameter of the fastener-the diameter of the shaft at the root of the threads. Typically, the manufacturer will specify a diameter for the pilot hole in their screw specs. Finally, note that some screws will be specified for particular plastic resins, so if you change your resin during prototyping you should make sure you're still looking at the right type of fastener.