Product designers build strength into their injection-moulded parts in different ways and for different reasons. Dissecting part application is a good first step in determining if additional strength should get designed into a part. How will customers be using your product and what environment will it live in? You may need parts that can withstand repetitive impact, resist wear or bear heavy loads. It may be as simple as integrating ribs or gussets into your design, or a more complicated combination of design elements involving support features, material, wall thickness and more. Finding the proper balance of design considerations will help address your part's need for strength and stability.
Ribs are thin, wall-like features typically designed into the geometry of a part to add internal support to walls or other features like bosses. In a similar fashion, gussets are support features that reinforce areas such as walls or bosses to the floor. Just as bridge beams and columns are supported at their vertex with gussets to add critical strength to the structure, the same concept applies to plastic injection moulding.
Both ribs and gussets provide stability in parts without having to increase wall thickness, and are particularly beneficial for parts with already thin walls that could potentially be compromised by end user wear and tear. It's important to note that ribs and gussets should be no more than 60 percent of nominal wall thickness. These features are kept thinner than the primary walls in an effort to avoid overly thick sections where ribs and gussets intersect with the wall. When you have a surplus of material meeting at internal rib-to-wall intersections, sink marks can appear on the visible side of the part.
Our Protomold Design Cube illustrates thick and thin ribs, proper use of gussets, well-designed bosses and other considerations to be mindful of when building strength into parts.*
Product designers can play with different ribbed formations to create square, rectangle, diamond, triangle or honeycomb patterns that stiffen the part. A pattern of ribs is equivalent to coring out unneeded material, leaving only the rib support system - it also reduces the weight and cost of the part. But, remember to not remove surfaces and features that interface with the other parts in the product assembly.
Because sharp corners weaken parts, fillets - curved faces where ribs meet walls - can also be designed into part geometry to eliminate additional mechanical stress concentrations on a finished part. Much like gussets, a fillet that is too small will fail to accomplish its task of stress reduction, but a fillet that is too large can once again create sink. Identifying the proper size and locations of fillets (and ribs and gussets) are important. When adding a fillet to the inside of a corner, also add a radius to the outside of the corner, if possible. If the risk of sink is too high in some sections, then other strength-building methods should be considered.
Material selection also plays a role in the stiffness, durability, toughness and other characteristics of parts; balancing the relationship between those material properties and part functionality is key. For example, product designers can choose a thermoplastic resin that will make a stiff, rigid part, but if its application demands a high degree of impact resistance, the brittleness of an inflexible part may cause it to break. Material properties differ from resin to resin - here's a glance at some of our more frequently used resins:
ABS is a good, stable consumer-grade resin that is tough and impact-resistant in daily use environments. It's commonly used in housings for remote controls, battery-powered tools and body panels for monitors, printers and copiers. There may be chemical resistance concerns with ABS.
Polycarbonate is more impact-resistant than ABS, and good for lenses and parts that require more shine. It is susceptible to stress cracking, and risks crazing/hazing due to chemical compatibility concerns.
Unfilled nylon is pliable and impact-resistant with good lubricity for wear. Glass-fibre filler increases nylon's stiffness and compressive strength, but the material becomes more brittle on impact. Glass-fibre filler helps increase heat deflection.
Acetal is an excellent self-lubricating bearing material with great wear properties and good stiffness. It's not good for cosmetic parts or parts that require pad printing, paint or decals.
TPEs are great for dust seals and padding corners for impact resistance, and used in overmoulding applications for grip features. They're not always good in dynamic applications; static applications are best. There may be chemical resistance concerns with TPE.
Reinforcing materials with an additive can also build strength into parts. Long and short glass fibres make resins stronger and stiffer (but more brittle), and carbon fibres can make resins even stiffer yet. Minerals such as talc and clay are often used as fillers to increase the hardness of finished parts; and glass beads and mica flakes are used to stiffen a part and reduce warping and shrink.
Sometimes, if you want to add strength to a part, you just have to increase overall wall thickness. Proto Labs provides a list of recommended wall thicknesses based on resin type to help design parts that are neither too thin nor too thick. The larger that parts get, the more attention needs to be paid to ribs, gussets, materials and other factors that improve strength. As usual, our Customer Service Engineers are available to discuss part geometry and design, and look for the interactive mouldability analysis that comes with every quoted part at Proto Labs.
*If you'd like a free Design Cube, get one here.