Protolabs Helps Scion-Sprays to win €4 million Order
When it needed fully functioning prototypes for an affordable, engine management system to impress a potential customer, Scion-Sprays Ltd, based at the Hethel Engineering Centre for advanced manufacturing, near Norwich, chose the award-winning, rapid manufacturing services of Protolabs®.
As governments around the world plan to bring in tougher laws on engine emissions in order to meet air-pollution and fuel consumption targets, this poses a huge challenge for the makers of small (<250cc) low-cost engines. They find themselves faced with a decision to either invest in the development of more efficient engines or see markets closed to them.
Thankfully, one young company in the East of England has developed another solution—and after years in development has recently secured their first commercial order. Scion-Sprays Ltd (www.scion-sprays.com) is made up of a group of engineers specialising in the development and manufacturing of affordable engine management systems that will give its OEM customers a real competitive advantage.
Richard Hoolahan, Manufacturing Manager, explains: “Our first commercial product is a fuel injection system specifically designed for a European manufacturer of light motorcycles and scooters. This new system will cut emissions of HC+NOx (the cause of photochemical air pollution) by around 35%, and CO emissions by over 80% compared with a standard engine. It will also save 30% on fuel.”
Founded in 2002 by Jeff Allen (a former Chief Engineer at Lotus Engineering) the firm grew out of research into the electrostatic atomisation of fuel. In the process, Jeff (who is now the firm’s Technical Director) came up with the idea of a small, low-cost ’constant volume displacement pump’ to control fuel flow rates. As Richard says, ”That pump proved to have greater market potential than the original research because of its efficient, clean-burn credentials and its simplicity.” So with backing from an ‘angel’ investor, who saw both the business and the environmental benefits of the technology, Jeff and a small team set about developing Scion-Sprays’ innovative engine management system called Pulse Count Injection (PCI) and with the help of rapid prototyping services firstcut® and protomold® from Protolabs, are now moving out of development and into production.
PCI works by calculating the amount of fuel needed in each engine cycle and then applying a precise number of pulses of a fixed volume of fuel across the cycle (to see more details, including computer models and a list of relevant patents, visit www.scionsprays. com). By 2006, Scion-Sprays had produced their first working PCI prototype, which in turn led to the development of a fully integrated Quantum Fuel Injection (QFI®) system. The modular design of the QFI system includes a throttle body (designed by Richard when he was the company’s Design Engineer), PCI technology, sensors, idle control and ignition.
Because it has no high pressure pump and significantly fewer moving parts, QFI is simpler to build and maintain than a standard fuel injection system based on Pulse Width Modulation (PWM). Nevertheless, PCI technology enables QFI to deliver metered fuel bursts at up to 1000Hz and fuel atomisation at 50-80 microns SMD. This combination of accuracy, reliability and “smart controls”, along with its low unit cost, makes QFI ideal for motorcycles and mopeds up to 250cc, and small utility-engines (such as those found in lawnmowers, strimmers and leaf-blowers), which cannot justify the additional cost of a standard PWM system. An added attraction for OEM’s is that the throttle body matches the carburettor footprint in existing engine designs with minimum additional wiring and sensors and QFI -enabled engines are also Euro 3 and China Stage 3 emissions compliant, and bio-fuel compatible.
It was while developing a prototype of their QFI for a prospective European customer in the early part of 2010 that Richard turned to Protolabs. “I needed about 15-20 pre-production QFI systems for customer -testing, which meant they had to be fully functional and made from similar, if not the same materials that would be used in actual production units. I used different rapid prototyping services to produce less-critical components,” says Richard, “but chose Protolabs for the throttle crank and the stepper motor arm because there could be no compromises in the mechanical qualities of those parts: and the production method and the materials would be very similar to what we would use in the final version.”
Richard decided to use Protolabs’ injection-moulding service to produce the stepper motor arm from glass-reinforced nylon. However, he says: “I chose Protolabs machining service to make the throttle crank from the same material, partly because I wanted to compare the processes and partly because creating a mould for the throttle crank would not have been cost-effective. At this stage in the product development, it is very important to minimise costs.”
Richard contacted Protolabs using the company’s two interactive, online quotation systems: protoquote® and firstquote®. Both systems let him upload his 3D CAD models and then within hours sent back an accurate quote – not an estimate.
“I was very impressed with the process,” says Richard, “it was so easy. Online quoting systems rarely work as advertised, but this time they did. The Protolabs systems gave us a complete price based on our CAD models; a price that was updated instantly when we changed the quantity or material, so we knew what we would pay for what we wanted. I also liked the personal touch! For example, Protolabs suggested a small, design refinement, in this case adding draft angles to help release the motor arm from the mould.”
The machined parts were delivered within three days of Richard accepting the quote: “And that was their standard delivery—they can do it even faster if want. The moulded parts took slightly longer but that is because the tooling required. Nevertheless, they were with me in a matter of days, not months, like other suppliers.”
Overall, Richard was he was very impressed with the service, including the quality of the finished components: “Protolabs delivered exactly what they said they could which was exactly what I wanted. The QFI system performed as it was designed to and, as a result, we secured our first commercial order from that European motorcycle maker worth €4 million over the next 3 years. We are now in the process of developing our manufacturing equipment and expanding our facilities at the Hethel Engineering Centre, where we design the system, electronics and software. I would be very happy to use Protolabs again. In fact, I need to make some more pre-production models for another potential customer, so we will be reordering very soon.”